HMRC Property Tax Enquiries and Disputes
Technical representation built around the legislation, transaction documents, evidence and a clear audit trail.
An HMRC enquiry or assessment involving property can place significant tax, interest and penalties at stake. Disputes may turn on the legal character of land, the facts of occupation or use, the existence of a business or partnership, the application of a relief, a valuation or whether the taxpayer took reasonable care.
LWC Cornerstone reviews the full file rather than responding only to HMRC’s latest letter. We establish the procedural position, identify statutory deadlines, reconstruct the transaction, test both the taxpayer’s and HMRC’s technical arguments and create an evidence schedule showing what each document proves.
We assist with SDLT enquiries, CGT and property-income issues, discovery assessments, information notices, penalties, statutory reviews, Alternative Dispute Resolution and tribunal preparation. The appropriate route depends on the strength of the evidence, the amount at stake and the procedural stage.
Our approach is candid. Where a position is weak, we explain why and focus on reducing exposure, correcting the record and presenting mitigation accurately. Where the position is supportable, we develop the technical analysis and evidence needed to defend it.
How we can help
Initial merits and deadline review
Chronology and evidence schedule
Responses to HMRC information requests
Technical submissions and statutory interpretation
Valuation and expert-evidence coordination
Penalty and reasonable-care arguments
Statutory review and Alternative Dispute Resolution
Appeal and tribunal preparation with legal advisers
When to seek advice
Ideally before exchange of contracts, signing binding documents or implementing a restructuring. Early advice generally provides the widest range of lawful options.
Frequently asked questions
Why has HMRC opened an enquiry?
HMRC may enquire into a return within statutory powers, based on risk assessment or information available to it. The opening letter should be checked for scope and deadlines.
What should I do first?
Preserve documents, note the response deadline and obtain advice before making substantive admissions or providing an incomplete account.
Can HMRC challenge an SDLT return?
Yes. HMRC may investigate classification, reliefs, consideration, residence, linked transactions, partnership treatment and other aspects of the return.
What is a discovery assessment?
It is a statutory mechanism allowing HMRC to assess tax it considers has been lost, subject to legal conditions and time limits.
Must every information request be answered?
Relevant information should be provided appropriately, but the legal basis, scope, privilege and proportionality of a request may require review.
Can penalties be reduced?
Potentially. Penalties depend on the behaviour, disclosure and statutory framework. Evidence of reasonable care and cooperation can be important.
What is a statutory review?
It is a review of an appealable decision by an HMRC officer not previously involved, available within the relevant procedural framework and time limits.
What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?
ADR is a facilitated process that may help resolve factual or communication issues. It does not replace the need to protect appeal rights and deadlines.
Will the case go to tribunal?
Some disputes do, but many are resolved through correspondence, review, amendment or ADR. Litigation decisions should be based on merits, cost and risk.
Why is an audit trail important?
A chronology, document schedule and clear record of advice and decisions help demonstrate the facts, the basis of the return and the conduct of the taxpayer and advisers.
If HMRC has contacted you, protect the deadline and obtain an early merits review.
About this content
Author: Ben Percival, LWC Cornerstone
Technical reviewer: Julie White ACA, LWC Cornerstone
Last reviewed: 14 September 2026
Sources considered: Applicable UK tax legislation, current HMRC and devolved tax-authority guidance, and relevant tribunal and court decisions.
Important: This content is general information only and does not constitute tax, legal, investment or financial advice.